CaseLaw
Odutola V. Papersack Ltd (2006) CLR 12(e) (SC)
Judgement delivered on December 15th 2006
Brief
Facts
The res in this litigation is 44 Eric Moore Road, Iganmu Industrial Estate in Lagos State. The 1st Plaintiff, now the 1st Appellant, is the original owner of the property. He is the founder and principal shareholder of the 2nd Plaintiff, now the 2nd Appellant. The 2nd Appellant is the assignee of the unexpired term and interest in the property with effect from 13th December, 1991. The 1st Appellant is the Managing Director of the 2nd Appellant. The case of the Appellant is that Thoresen and Co. (Nig.) Ltd. rented the property and not Papersack Nigeria Limited. Although the tenancy expired in 1980, Respondent still occupied the property. They paid rent to the 1st Appellant, though not regularly. The 1st Appellant issued receipts for payments made by the Respondent.
Following the failure on the part of the Respondent to pay the rent, the Appellants filed the action. They claimed possession, outstanding rent and mesne profit. The Respondent made a counter-claim. After the conclusion of trial, the learned trial Judge entered judgment in favour of the Appellants.
On appeal to the Court of Appeal by the Respondent, the Court of Appeal set aside the judgment of the High Court.
Dissatisfied the Appellants appealed to the Supreme Court.